Not sure what to do with clients backing out of "commissions"

[rebeccaannoying.livejournal.com]

Edit: I derped up with wording, so editing to clarify |D

So I have posted here before with advice about specific clients, but this is the fourth time someone has backed out on me after agreeing to (and starting!) a project. I should mention that my commission process is highly unusual; at the moment, I only charge for materials and offer labor for free. I have a couple reasons for this: first, since I am still learning I don't feel that I can offer accurate time quotes. I do give a time range that the project will be complete (usually a few weeks, although it depends on the project), but I don't feel comfortable setting hard deadlines. This is not to say I won't consistently work on the project, but I don't want to make a promise I may not be able to keep. Hence I compensate my clients for this risk by discounting labor.  Second, these commissions are great learning experiences in terms of timing myself and figuring out how to give accurate quotes for both materials and time. I also favor clients who attend conventions more than I do because hey, free advertising! Finally, the money they save on labor is more money we can put towards high quality materials, and I much prefer to work that way. Sometimes I will have the client purchase tools as a small compensation for labor, but it's not always necessary. They get a commission at a steep discount in exchange for giving me the opportunity to experiment and build my portfolio.

So far I have worked exclusively with friends. I'm hesitant to open these to the great wide internet because frankly, I'm putting out a ton of effort for these projects and I want to work with people I trust. I thought working for friends would be less risky, but apparently not. Most recently, I had someone back out of a full body cosplay because he spontaneously decided to move across the country and no longer has the money to spend. This is fine except I've already put in 13.5 hours into research and pattern drafting.

I'm not sure if what I'm asking for is even possible, but I'm wondering if there is a way to offer these sort of commissions outside my group of friends without getting burned. For starters I'm thinking of requesting all material funds up front instead of letting people do payment plans, and I’m also considering a cancelation fee. I don’t know how to figure out a cancellation fee, but maybe that will make people take it more seriously. To be honest I’m kind of confused that this is happening; every time someone takes one of my bigger projects to a convention I get notes asking about commissions, so I assume my quality of work is at least OK? I just wanna build cool cosplays, and I want to do it so badly that I’ll give away my time.

Comments

[fralea comms (from livejournal.com)]

To be a little more clear, some customers will want firm deadlines if they are going to be needing something for an event, obviously. But you certainly wouldn't be out of line to only take deadlines that are a certain distance away that you feel gives you more than enough time for completion, for example, over 2 months, and then rejecting or charging a rush fee for any projects with deadlines shorter than that.

[rebeccaannoying.livejournal.com]

So how soft is an acceptably soft deadline, and what would be considered inappropriate overshooting? The worst time it happened for me was when I went from part time to full time, so what was supposed to take 5 weeks stretched out to 8. So far I have declined projects that had a near (like less than 4 months) deadline just in case.

And yes, I have heard of DTDs! I have worked with them before, but since they are less common for cosplay I'd like to learn how to custom fit clothes from measurements. Hence it would be super duper if I could work with someone locally so they could try things on. It also makes things easier to fix since some problems don't show up until a couple hours of wear. I will probably practice with a few more pre-made items that don't need to be closely fitted for the near future. If/when I do open for commissions, should I offer something like an extended warranty for the first couple of customers, or is it generally accepted that newbie products might have some flaws?

[fralea comms (from livejournal.com)]

Mmmm like I said I don't do this type of art so I am probably not the best person to ask. I say as long as you keep the customer informed and offer refunds if you aren't going to be able to work for an extended time then you are fine. Most customers I work with are happy to wait as long as they see updates and progress.

HMMMM I really don't know. What I've seen before is that the customer can send the item back for repairs if they don't do anything to it themselves or put it through excessive stress. So if they wear it the first time and a sleeve falls off, it can be fixed for free, but if they were trying to alter it themselves or going dirtbiking in it or something it voids the warranty. There should definitely be some kind of deadline though, you wouldn't want to be repairing things that people have had and worn for years. You probably know better than anyone how long your own work should hold up for before normal wear and tear sets in.